Where's The Toaster? is the 19th episode of Season 2. In this episode, Shy Guy's toaster has gone missing.
- Shy Guy
- SuperMarioGlitchy4 (brief cameo sleeping in the castle)
- Bandit Gang
- SuperEmiga (cameo)
- Bowser Jr. (mentioned)
- Superluigiglitchy4 (mentioned)
- Weegee (cameo)
- Coco (cameo)
- When Wiggler mentions "a toaster, a lamp, a blanket, a radio and a vacuum cleaner", he is referencing the 1987 Disney film, The Brave Little Toaster.
- Bowser mentioning "a show about a cucumber missing his hairbrush" is a (obvious) reference to the VeggieTales song, The Hairbrush Song.
- Farawaylands might be a parody of Far Far Away from the Shrek movies.
- Mario's Pokemon from Super Pokeman 64 Bloopers reappear.
- For a split second, SuperMarioGlitchy4 can be seen dozing in the castle.
- During Alex's breakdown when she confesses to have lost the toaster, she wails, "The B-B-B-Bandit Gang found it! Th-th-th-they stole your toaster! And now it's in their caravan, never to be seen again! *sniff* And it's all my fault, just like when I said we should trust Coco!" she is referencing The Secret of the Sapphire Door, where she and Coco made their debut in the SM64 Blooper series.